In 'lifeboat ethics: the case against the poor,' what is the author's main argument?

4 answers
Question:

In "lifeboat ethics: the case against the poor," what is the author's
main argument?

Answers

Answer and explanation:

Garret Hardin, the author of "Lifeboat Ethics", does not believe equality in sharing the planet's resources could be easily achieved as the environmentalists do.

"Lifeboat Ethics" is an essay published in 1974 in which Hardin discusses how wrong he thinks environmentalists are when they compare our planet to a spaceship. According to the author, environmentalists are too idealistic when they claim that no person or institution has the right to destroy, waste, or use more than a fair share of the "spaceship's" resources, since we all live in it.

Hardin compares our planet's countries to lifeboats, the rich countries being the lifeboats full of rich people, the poor countries being the poor people swimming in the ocean - that comparison comes from the known fact that, when ships sank, rich people were prioritized to be saved. A poor person would want to climb into a lifeboat, but there is a lot to be taken into consideration before allowing them to do so, such as the lifeboat's capacity. That metaphor means that simply lending a hand and helping out can be damaging to the one helping. Thus, international aid must be done with due caution. Hardin defends the idea that a rich country must think of its own economy and situation first, prioritizing its own survival.

In "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor," the author's main argument is "The author is against foreign aid to starving nations because he thinks it causes a cycle of poor resource management."

Explanation:

In "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor" the author states that poor countries represent a burden to the planet in terms of use of resources and to other countries due to the economic and active help they send to poorer countries, the author explains that if richer countries stopped helping poorer ones, their population will be reduced because of the lack of food and aid, en eventually as their population reduces the poverty and burden they cause will do to.

In the book "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor," the author presents an argument that is likely to be controversial for most people. The author tells us that he believes it is not necessary or even good to help the poor. However, the author also provides justification for his proposition. He tells us that foreign aid often brings more problems than solutions. He also believes that many problems poor countries face are not going to be solved by having more money, but by having better education and institutions.

The right answer is A.

Similar Solved Works

2 answers

Form the intersection for the following sets.R = {10, 15, 20)S = {20, 25)RAS =OO(10, 15, 25)O

Form the intersection for the following sets. R = {10, 15, 20) S = {20, 25) RAS = OO (10, 15, 25) O [20] (10, 15, 20, 25)...
7 answers

6ft and 10ft =? it's the pythagorean theorem

6ft and 10ft =? it's the pythagorean theorem...
4 answers

What were reasons or expanding us westward

What were reasons or expanding us westward...
4 answers

Jackie has 120 apps on her phone, which is 6 times as many as her younger sister. How many apps does Jackie’s younger sister have?

Jackie has 120 apps on her phone, which is 6 times as many as her younger sister. How many apps does Jackie’s younger sister have?...
4 answers

Paying anybody 300$ to do my online summer school for geometry .. serious inquiries only

Paying anybody 300$ to do my online summer school for geometry .. serious inquiries only...
4 answers

Victoria es 8 años menor que Mónica y hace diez años la edad de aquella era rac {4}{5} de la ésta. ¿Cuáles son las edades

Victoria es 8 años menor que Mónica y hace diez años la edad de aquella era \frac {4}{5} de la ésta. ¿Cuáles son las edades actuales?...
6 answers

PLEASE HELP ME!Glacier National Park spans one million acres of protected mountains, glaciers, and lakes. It forms part of the Continental

PLEASE HELP ME! Glacier National Park spans one million acres of protected mountains, glaciers, and lakes. It forms part of the Continental Divide. On Triple Divide Peak, the Continental Divide meets the Northern Divide. Here, water can flow to the Atlantic, Pacific, or Arctic Oceans. Fortunately, ...
4 answers

What is the inverse of the linerar functiony = - 0.007x + 50.913

What is the inverse of the linerar function y = - 0.007x + 50.913...
3 answers

The closing process is necessary in order to

The closing process is necessary in order to...
2 answers

For birthday party mr. perkins orders ate chocolate chip cookies and 16 sugar cookies. each cookies

For birthday party mr. perkins orders ate chocolate chip cookies and 16 sugar cookies. each cookies the same price. he also picked up a cupcake for himself, which costs $2.75. the total bill is $44.03. what is the cost of a cookie?...
4 answers

Smith Corp. is in the process of liquidating and going out of business. The firm has $20,000 in cash, inventory totaling $1,000,000,

Smith Corp. is in the process of liquidating and going out of business. The firm has $20,000 in cash, inventory totaling $1,000,000, accounts receivable of $200,000, plant and equipment with a $400,000 book value, and total liabilities of $700,000. It is estimated that the inventory can be disposed ...
4 answers

You find a soil sample with 50 percent sand 20 pecent silt and 40 percent clay

You find a soil sample with 50 percent sand 20 pecent silt and 40 percent clay...
7 answers

What is the 'first lesson' described in the poem by this name

What is the "first lesson" described in the poem by this name...
4 answers

It takes to break an iodine-iodine single bond. Calculate the maximum wavelength of light for which an iodine-iodine single bond

It takes to break an iodine-iodine single bond. Calculate the maximum wavelength of light for which an iodine-iodine single bond could be broken by absorbing a single photon....
3 answers

Find the amount paid for the loan. $2400 at 10.5% for 5 years

Find the amount paid for the loan. $2400 at 10.5% for 5 years...
3 answers

How did american politics change in the aftermath of the 1854 kansas-nebraska act?

How did american politics change in the aftermath of the 1854 kansas-nebraska act?...
3 answers

Data is in sequence if it is in order from lowest to highest

Data is in sequence if it is in order from lowest to highest...
10 answers

Can you guys pretty me with my science

Can you guys pretty me with my science [tex]Can you guys pretty me with my science[/tex]...
3 answers

Suzanne sells authentic Amish quilts on her website. Suppose Suzanne expects to sell 1 comma 600 quilts

Suzanne sells authentic Amish quilts on her website. Suppose Suzanne expects to sell 1 comma 600 quilts during the coming year. Her average sales price per quilt is $ 325​, and her average cost per quilt is $ 125. Her fixed expenses total $ 160 comma 000. Compute her margin of safety a. in units...
2 answers

G Mason Company paid its annual property taxes of $240,000 on February 15, 20X9. Mason also anticipates that its annual repairs

g Mason Company paid its annual property taxes of $240,000 on February 15, 20X9. Mason also anticipates that its annual repairs expense for 20X9 will be $1,200,000. This amount is usually incurred and paid in July and August when operations are shut down so that machinery and equipment can be repair...

-- 0.020238--